Look only at Toledo's citywide numbers and winter seems like the buyer's season. Last February, single-family homes in the city's 15 ZIP codes took an average of 75 days to sell, and sellers received 97.7% of their list price, according to the Northwest Ohio REALTORS February 2026 market report. In July 2026 the same figures were 54 days and 99.7%. That's about two points of negotiating room and three extra weeks to decide.
That two-point discount came from a handful of ZIP codes. On much of the west and south side, the number of homes for sale fell by a third to a half between October 2025 and January 2026, and sellers there kept getting close to full price. Before you plan a winter purchase around getting a deal, find out which kind of winter your ZIP code had.
The citywide winter, month by month
Here is the city as a whole, from last fall through this one. These figures come from the Northwest Ohio REALTORS monthly reports, which use NORIS MLS data, and they cover single-family homes in the "Toledo - All Zip Codes" group: 43604 through 43623.
| Toledo, all ZIPs | Median price | Days on market | % of list received | Homes for sale | Months of supply |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| October 2025 | $165,000 | 57 | 100.3% | 770 | 2.9 |
| November 2025 | $145,000 | 67 | 97.9% | 789 | 3.0 |
| January 2026 | $135,000 | 66 | 98.6% | 589 | 2.2 |
| February 2026 | $145,000 | 75 | 97.7% | 590 | 2.2 |
| July 2026 | $162,000 | 54 | 99.7% | 723 | 2.7 |
| October 2026 | $157,000 | 59 | 99.7% | 798 | 3.0 |
One column runs against the usual winter story. Homes did take longer to sell last winter, and sellers did get a bit less of their asking price. But months of supply fell from 3.0 in November 2025 to 2.2 in January and February 2026. Months of supply estimates how long the current listings would last at the recent pace of sales, so a lower number means a tighter market. New listings dropped to 230 in both January and February 2026, down from 405 in October 2025 and 286 in November 2025. The number of homes for sale shrank faster than the number of buyers.
Toledo's winter is slower, but it isn't looser. Fewer people are shopping, and those people have fewer homes to choose from. Where those two drops land depends on the part of town.
Where the winter discount came from
Two central ZIP codes pulled the citywide percent-of-list figure down. In 43608, homes sold for 88.2% of list in January 2026 and 87.4% in February. In 43607, the February figure was 90.6%, with 4.1 months of supply, the loosest market of any ZIP with meaningful sales volume.
Lower price points don't explain it on their own. In 43605, February 2026 sales closed at 100.8% of list, at a $55,000 median, with 3.0 months of supply. These are neighboring ZIP codes with similar price ranges, and their winter negotiating room came out very differently.
The ZIPs that got tighter in January
On the south and west side, the winter pattern ran the other way. Supply dropped further than the citywide average, and in most of these ZIPs sellers kept getting about full price.
| ZIP | Homes for sale, Oct 2025 | Homes for sale, Jan 2026 | Months of supply, Feb 2026 | % of list, Jan / Feb 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 43614 | 53 | 31 | 1.2 | 99.1% / 100.8% |
| 43615 | 63 | 42 | 1.2 | 100.0% / 101.0% |
| 43623 | 53 | 27 | 1.2 | 97.2% / 97.6% |
| 43611 | 53 | 28 | 1.3 | 100.8% / 96.8% |
| 43613 | 93 | 76 | 2.4 | 99.9% / 99.7% |
In 43614, months of supply fell to 1.1 in January 2026, the tightest reading of any ZIP in the city that month. A buyer shopping 43614 that month had about 31 single-family listings to choose from. On the other side of town, 43607 had 58.
The 43623 row is the exception. Its inventory roughly halved from October 2025 to January 2026, yet sellers took about 97% of list in both January and February 2026. A few points of give showed up there even with very few listings. In 43611, the January and February figures pointed in opposite directions. Both ZIPs also show a limit of these numbers. 43623 had 14 closings in January and 13 in February, and 43611 had 15 each month. With that few sales, two or three unusual homes can move a monthly percentage. Treat a single month for a single ZIP as a direction, not a verdict.
Inventory is the steadier signal. Every ZIP in that table had fewer homes for sale in January 2026 than in October 2025, and four of the five lost a third or more. For a buyer, the winter cost on this side of town is fewer homes to choose from, not higher prices.
Why the citywide median drops every winter
The citywide median was $165,000 in October 2025 and $135,000 in January 2026. That looks like winter discounting, but much of the gap comes from which ZIP codes are doing the selling.
Look at closings. In 43614, closed sales went from 35 in July 2026 to 11 in February 2026. In 43623 the same months had 28 and 13. Both are ZIPs with medians above $200,000. Meanwhile, 43605 had 20 closings in February 2026 and 16 in July 2026. When higher-priced ZIPs make up less of the month's sales, the citywide median falls, even if no individual home sold for less than it would have in summer.
Prices within single ZIPs did move. 43615's median was $164,750 in January 2026 and $200,503 in July 2026. But a $30,000 gap in the citywide median doesn't mean a typical home costs $30,000 less in January. It means the January sales came from a different part of the city.
What October tells you about the winter ahead
The newest report covers October 2026. Its data was current as of November 6, and November figures normally come out in early December. In October 2026, Toledo homes sold for 99.7% of list, with 798 single-family homes for sale and 3.0 months of supply. Both inventory figures were a little higher than in October 2025. Northwest Ohio REALTORS' October summary for Lucas and Wood counties said inventory "remains limited, although buyers may have slightly more room to negotiate than they did last year."
By ZIP, several west and south side ZIPs were still selling above list in October 2026, with 43623 at 105.6%, 43613 at 103.0% and 43614 at 102.8%. 43620 was at 91.3% with 9.3 months of supply, but that figure rests on 4 sales. 43608 was at 91.3% with 3.5 months of supply.
If this winter follows last winter, the ZIPs with tight inventory now will get tighter. Last year, 43614 went from 53 homes for sale in October 2025 to 31 in January 2026. This October it started at 62, and 43615 started at 77, up from 63 a year earlier. With a higher starting point, January may not get quite as tight as it did last year. Even so, last year's pattern is the best guide in these reports.
The same October summary said the condo and villa market was moving the other way, with longer selling times and more inventory. Northwest Ohio REALTORS wrote that condo and villa buyers "may find more options, additional time to make decisions and greater negotiating opportunities." A buyer willing to look at attached homes may get the winter that single-family buyers in 43614 won't.
Reading this as a buyer
If you're shopping in 43614, 43615 or 43611 this winter, plan for fewer listings, not lower prices. Expect to see less in January than you would have in October, and expect sellers of well-priced homes to hold close to their number. A mortgage pre-approval and a clear list of must-haves count for more when the right house may be one of 30. Northwest Ohio REALTORS recommended both in its August 2026 market commentary. Our buyer page is a good place to start that prep.
If your search includes 43607 or 43608, last winter's numbers show real room to negotiate on price. Homes there also sat longer, so ask why a particular house hasn't sold and decide whether you're comfortable with the answer.
Reading this as an owner
If you own in a ZIP where inventory drops sharply by January and you're deciding between listing in winter and waiting for spring, last year's numbers say winter isn't a penalty. A January 2026 seller in 43614 competed with about 30 other listings and averaged 99.1% of list. A seller in 43615 that month averaged 100.0%. A home listed in that month gets the attention of every buyer still looking. Selling times in those ZIPs were longer, from 48 days in 43614 in January to 85 days in 43615 in February, so build that into your moving plans. If you want to see where your home falls before deciding, request a home valuation, and see our sellers page for how we approach a listing.
If you're weighing a winter move and want the numbers for your own ZIP code instead of the citywide average, reach out to Justin Spann and we'll go through how the last few months have gone on your side of town and what that means for your timing. Let's Connect.